Sign Up Now!

Is sharing the names we've picked a bad idea?

I know people mean well and I'm excited to tell them when they ask but sometimes they're not very good at hiding their dislike of the names we've picked. From now on I'm just going to keep it to myself and tell them we don't know yet.

Anyone else get this response...their voice goes high and they say "pretty."

Posted: July 23, 2008
By: KathyGB

15 Replies

With our 1st, a girl that we adopted at birth, we picked out a boys name and a girls name that we loved but kept it to ourselvles. (the birthmother didn't know if it was a girl or boy) Everyone was furious because we kept the name to ourselves. Abby Grace just turned 3 and we found out this summer we are pregnant, with a girl. Scince everyone was so mad that we kept the names to ourselves last time we decided to share this time. Big mistake!! When my mother in law begged to know, I told her we were going to name her Carys Paige.....I got "oh, so you're going to call her Paige?" I said "No, her name is Carys" When I told my mother, she said " Oh........Well thats a pretty name, I just never heard it before" My advice.....DONT SHARE! Keep something for yourselves until the baby comes. You are the ones who are naming YOUR baby. Don't let anyone influence you or make you choose a name you don't like.

KimB | October 16, 2008


Oh names, names. It's crazy,IMO, but people can be really cruel, especially family. My husband is a "II - second" and so there was a LOT of pressure from his family to name our first son after him, continuing the tradition that his dad had started. I was okay with that, but he was NOT - he hated not having his own name and always getting things like bank accounts confused with his dad. So we decided not to tell anyone. We chose family names for the first and middle names - one from each side and just announced it after he was born. Neither name went over really well - even though they were family names, but people didn't say much because there wasn't anything they could do about it at that point. Plus, there was a cute little baby to go with it.

With our second son, we again picked family names for his first and middle names, but this time we told and I'm sorry we did. I had a really close relationship with my husband's paternal Grandmother, Grace, and we named our son after her - Grayson. Middle name Fredrick, after the men in my family. We got grief for it sounding so old - TONS of questions about spelling and lectures about NOT spelling it "Gracen". We caved and stuck with "Grayson", even after his grandmother passed away two weeks before our son was born, something that I will always regret just a little. So for him, I'm only glad we told because his namessake would have passed before she found out and that was worth it to me, otherwise I would have just kept it a secret like the first time. Frist son - Alphred (Alphie) Clair; both named after grandfathers in our families.

ssadams | October 14, 2008


Oh names, names. It's crazy,IMO, but people can be really cruel, especially family. My husband is a "II - second" and so there was a LOT of pressure from his family to name our first son after him, continuing the tradition that his dad had started. I was okay with that, but he was NOT - he hated not having his own name and always getting things like bank accounts confused with his dad. So we decided not to tell anyone. We chose family names for the first and middle names - one from each side and just announced it after he was born. Neither name went over really well - even though they were family names, but people didn't say much because there wasn't anything they could do about it at that point. Plus, there was a cute little baby to go with it.

With our second son, we again picked family names for his first and middle names, but this time we told and I'm sorry we did. I had a really close relationship with my husband's paternal Grandmother, Grace, and we named our son after her - Grayson. Middle name Fredrick, after the men in my family. We got grief for it sounding so old - TONS of questions about spelling and lectures about NOT spelling it "Gracen". We caved and stuck with "Grayson", even after his grandmother passed away two weeks before our son was born, something that I will always regret just a little. So for him, I'm only glad we told because his namessake would have passed before she found out and that was worth it to me, otherwise I would have just kept it a secret like the first time. Frist son - Alphred (Alphie) Clair; both named after grandfathers in our families.

ssadams | October 14, 2008


I am pregnant with my third and we haven't and won't tell anyone the baby names we like. Once we have the baby we just announce the name and that's that. I like unique names (nothing too crazy or spelled weird, we just don't pick names from the top 100 list--my 2 boys have names that did not make the SSA top 1000 list when we picked them) and I don't want anyone to influence me or make me think twice about what I have picked. If someone hates the names I like that would obviously make me feel upset and if they like the names alot then I worry that everyone else will like them too and then they will get to be too popular in a few years so either way I just don't want to hear their opinions. It does make everyone around me--especially my mother in law--kind of crazy but it saves me from losing sleep over my choices and second guessing myself. Since we do find out the sex of the baby and announce that to everyone, I like that the name is a surprise until the end.

As far as teasing goes (jamieW), I truly think that if a child is going to be teased by someone then they are going to be teased no matter what their name is. I think teasing a child has little to do with someone's name, if a bully wants to tease a certain child they will find a way to make fun of them or their name regardless of what it is.

Alesha | October 11, 2008


When we told people we were naming our first daughter Amelia we got many comments of "Oh, like Amelia Bedelia." I politely corrected them that we were actually naming her after a childhood hero of mine, Amelia Earhart and left it at that. Now she's 3 and it really doesn't bother me what people say.

If you are firm in your decision of what names you like then make sure you have thick enough skin to ignore comments or else a short explanation of why you love the names you love. My other daughter is Daisy after my grandma and we got a few of the high pitched "pretty" comments with that name choice. I figure whatever name you choose people will have their personal opinions about it. Let them think what they want (they're going to anyway... lol).

katdancing | October 10, 2008


With both of our kids we waited until we had the names fully picked out and were confident with our choices, then we just said "this is the name we picked out", I think if you sound unsure of your choices then people feel like your still looking for others input.

mzmom | October 7, 2008


I think it depends on how thick skinned you are. If other people's opinions will not affect you, then go ahead and share. for me, other people's opinions bothered me, so a few names were ruined by other's veiwpoints. With our 3rd baby we did not share name ideas.

rnmomof3 | October 7, 2008


We haven't really told anyone our choices yet, except for my mom. She was very open about not liking them. But that's cool, I am pretty confident with our choices, so I don't mind if no one else like them. I know they rock. Well, to me, anyway, and that's all that matters.

ESharp | October 6, 2008


We get that alot too, if its a girl we want to name her Shelby (our last name is Ford..so she'll be Shelby Ford...as in a Shelby Ford Mustang) *sigh* We both love the name, and i think its cute and ironic, but everyone's like "ohh. nice." Its annoying.

robertswifey327 | September 12, 2008


I think you should tell other people and get their opinions. If you pick a name and 98% of the people you talk to say "pretty" in a high voice, then you've obviously chosen a name that's gonna result in playground teasing for your child... and you don't want that, do u?

jamieW | August 4, 2008


I believe in getting feedback from folks. I think most folks are not careful when choosing a name, and they are not thinking about the many ways their child can be teased because of their name. My father warned me to choose names that were easy and simple because kids like to tease. If your okay with this and think you can handle it when your child is teased, then don't worry about what name you choose. In addition, there are always those folks that , have something to say about everything and there is always one in a crowd. Unfortunately, I do not think you are going to be able to please everyone. Be confident with the name you choose and don't worry about what others think. At the end of the day, it is just an opinion and the only one that matters is yours.

ali9599 | October 14, 2008


We got the same thing when we told our friends that we were going to name our first son Rufus Jamal Dilley.

bdilley | August 1, 2008


I think you should keep it to yourself and make sure it's YOUR decision-- not influenced by anyone else. In the end, this is your child, and you're the one who gets to hear the name every day, so make your decisions for yourself.

HelsNests | August 1, 2008


Coming from someone who wound up naming her boys Joe and Michael this may not carry much weight but don't count on the names you've picked to be the final choice. I and friends waited until day two to fill in the birth certificate. Clearly I buckled under pressure and resorted to the safe choices.

HeatherN | July 23, 2008


YES!!! This has been driving me nuts. Definitely don't tell the in-laws. Or maybe pick a couple of decoys. Have some fun with it maybe...?

LandisMom | July 23, 2008


To post a reply, you must be logged in. Get an Account Login